MARCH 2022

Sh500 million Karen land dispute case adjourned

Justice Maureen Odero said she was out on official duty

In Summary

•Early November a brother to a deceased Kenyan of British descent, Roger Robson, told the court the signature on the will was that of his late brother.

•Michael Robson verified his brothers signature on the will and he believed that Guy Spencer was the legal legitimate executor for his brother.

Nairobi businesswoman Ann Kagure
Nairobi businesswoman Ann Kagure
Image: HANDOUT

A Sh500 million Karen land dispute case pitting British-born lawyer Guy Spencer and politician Agnes Kagure on Tuesday failed to start.

Justice Maureen Odero adjourned the case saying she was out on official duty.

The case was pushed to March 14, 2022.

Early November, a brother to a deceased Kenyan of British descent, Roger Robson, told the court the signature on the will was that of his late brother.

Michael Robson verified his brother's signature on the will and he believed that Guy Spencer was the legal legitimate executor for his brother.

He denied claims the Sh500 million disputed property in Karen was sold to politician Agnes Kagure.

Michael said his brother- Roger - had owned and lived at Ushirika Road until he was taken to Nairobi West Hospital by Jackson Mulinge on August 5, 2012.

“I disagree that Kagure took over the property when my brother died. My brother was still in possession of the asset in 2012,” he said.

Michael said he is aware that Kagure is laying claim on No95 Ushirika Road on the basis that she purports to have purchased it from Rogers in November 2011 and that she has been in possession since then.

He said Rogers wrote a letter to him on March 31, 2011. There was no indication that he was considering selling the property.

“Roger had before his death informed me on several occasions that fraudsters were attempting to steal his residence by falsely claiming ownership but he was being assisted to resist these fraudulent claims,” Michael said.

The witness confirmed that Roger remained in possession of the land and that he would neither have sold nor entered into any agreement to sell it.

Michael was testifying virtually from the United Kingdom in a case in which Guy Spencer has been accused of forging Rogers (his client’s)will. 

Kagure has been laying claim to the said land.

She alleges to have bought the disputed piece of land from Roger for Sh100 million in 2011 and later accused Spencer of planning to transfer the property to himself and dispose of it.

She accused Elms of forging Roger's will. The will was signed on March 24, 1997.

Michael told the court he is not a beneficiary of the will and that his relationship with his brother was difficult.

He said Plovers’ Haunt limited has always been owned by his family and at no point has it been managed by one Thomas Mutaha or Peter Gaitho.

The two claim to be directors of the company.

The witness said his late brother would never have entered willingly into any agreement to sell or transfer Plovers’ Huant Limited or any of the assets during his lifetime.  

Edited by Kiilu Damaris

WATCH: The latest videos from the Star