High Court upholds DPP’s evidence in ex-MP Muchai murder, four put on Defence

A court gavel

The Director of Public Prosecutions has secured a breakthrough in the long-running case of the brutal murder of former Kabete MP George Muchai, with the High Court in Nairobi ruling that four accused persons have a case to answer.

In a ruling delivered by Justice Kanyi Kimondo, the court affirmed that the DPP had established a strong prima facie sight case against Eric Mungera Isabwa, Raphael Kimani Gachii, Mustafa Kimani Anyoni, and Stephen Astiva Lipopo.

The four are accused of orchestrating the cold-blooded killing of Muchai, his two police bodyguards namely Constable Samuel Kimathi and Constable Samuel Lekakeny alongside his driver, Stephen Ituu Wambugu, along Kenyatta Avenue in February 2015.

This development follows an intensive prosecution, which successfully called 37 witnesses, presenting a blend of direct, circumstantial, and documentary evidence to link the accused to the heinous crime.

Among the testimonies was that of a protected taxi driver who placed one of the accused, Mustafa Kimani Anyoni, at the centre of the crime and produced a gun safety pin discovered in his vehicle, later confirmed as evidence.

In detailed submissions filed by Principal Prosecution Counsel Peris Maina, the DPP demonstrated that the killings were not random but premeditated, pointing to the accused persons’ use of dangerous weapons and the execution-style shootings as evidence of careful planning.

Autopsy reports by government pathologist Johansen Oduor confirmed all four victims died of close-range gunshot wounds from high-velocity firearms.

Justice Kimondo, while placing the accused on their defence, acknowledged the strength of the prosecution’s case, though he refrained from making findings on parallel robbery-with-violence charges pending before a Nairobi magistrate’s court.

The three co-accused, Jane Wanjiru Kamau, Margaret Njeri Wachiuri, and Simon Wambugu Gichamba were acquitted after the court found insufficient evidence against them.

DPP said the ruling underscores its steadfast commitment to pursuing justice in one of Kenya’s most high-profile political assassinations.

The case now proceeds to defence hearing on October 22, 2025, where the four accused will be required to respond to the weight of evidence marshaled by the prosecution.